<body><script type="text/javascript"> function setAttributeOnload(object, attribute, val) { if(window.addEventListener) { window.addEventListener('load', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }, false); } else { window.attachEvent('onload', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }); } } </script> <div id="navbar-iframe-container"></div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://apis.google.com/js/platform.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> gapi.load("gapi.iframes:gapi.iframes.style.bubble", function() { if (gapi.iframes && gapi.iframes.getContext) { gapi.iframes.getContext().openChild({ url: 'https://www.blogger.com/navbar/14058325?origin\x3dhttp://croydonian.blogspot.com', where: document.getElementById("navbar-iframe-container"), id: "navbar-iframe" }); } }); </script>

Does the UK actually have a door policy?

Monday, November 05, 2007
Say hello to Colonel Karuna Amman, known to his nearest and dearest as Vinayagamoorthi Muralitharan, leader of a faction that broke away from the Tamil separatist group LTTE in Sri Lanka.

The Hindustan Times reports on this character under the headline "Karuna seeks political asylum in UK".

Now read on......

"Karuna...was accused by the UN...of indulging in large-scale extortion and recruitment of kids for his armed group in the Tamil-speaking Eastern districts of Batticaloa and Amparai. And the Sri Lankan government was accused of being "complicit" in his crimes. Isolated and unwanted, Karuna fled Sri Lanka recently, and was reportedly living in the UK". Source

And there's more: "Colonel Karuna was the LTTE head of the Eastern province in 1990, when between 400 to 600 unarmed police officers who surrendered to the group were consequently massacred. When Colonel Karuna was part of the LTTE, he was also implicated in the massacre of Muslims... RSF (Reporters Without Borders), has accused him of muzzling local journalists by forming death squads to silence those who oppose his point of view.

His armed group has been accused by human rights groups in the increasing involuntary disappearances of civilians in the Jaffna peninsula. They have been accused of taking part in death squad activity against civilians. They are also accused of child soldier recruitment by UNICEF, Human Rights Watch, and others. Additionally, a report by the United States Department of State claims that Karuna's group "was believed also to have killed 20 civilians."

I expect "Customs and Immigration" rolled out the red carpet.



Labels:

With friends like these...

Wednesday, October 31, 2007
A poll of urban Pakistanis:

"Do you favour or oppose the Pakistani army entering federally administered tribal areas to pursue and capture al Qaeda fighters?"

Favour - 44%
Oppose - 36%

However, going after Taliban types is a bit more popular, at 48%. This does rather beg the question as to what the confused 4% would do about mixed AQ/Taliban camps.

And as to letting their Uncle Sam do the same:

Favour - 5%
Oppose - 80%

Meanwhile, the outlook for secularism in Pakistan is not good - 60% want more sharia law.

The Federally Administered Tribal Area has a web site all of its very own, and news is to be found at the 'whats up' (sic) tab. And lo and behold, a click reveals, "NO NEWS FOUND".

More promising is the list of books in the FATA's library, including 'Enjoy Afghanistan - An Orientation Manual for Expatriate Workers'. Which is NOT a hoax, as I have found details. 'The Khattak - A Restless People' by Muhammed Nawaz Khan also sounds a good read.


Labels: ,

Polling in Afghanistan

Friday, October 19, 2007
The Globe & Mail, and sundry other Canadian media organisations have paid to have the unfortunate people of Afghanistan polled on the issues of the day, and the results are quite noteworthy. While polling in Helmand is unlikely to be as straightforward / accurate as polling in the Yukon or Ontario, there is a full breakdown of statistical method, and it deserves to be taken seriously. There is a heightened emphasis on Kandahar, as our Canadian friends are based there.

So, the Big One:

What do Afghans think about the multitude of foreign countries that have been present in their country over the past five years? Most believe this has been a positive presence. Six in ten (60%) Afghans say the foreign presence is a good thing for their country, compared with 16 percent who say it is a bad thing; another 22 percent are more ambivalent...Are the foreign countries doing a good job fighting the Taliban? Yes, say nearly two thirds (64%) of
Afghans, versus 17 percent who say a bad job (in Kandahar, 58% say a good job versus 27% who disagree.

So, pretty good, all things considered.

But not this: In terms of public awareness of the presence of foreign countries (covering all functions and roles), Canada ranks fourth after the United States (95%), Germany (63%), the U.K. (52%) and then Canada at 46 percent.

I think that is a bit raw given that the British are by far the second biggest contributor to NATO forces after the Americans.

And "Who, top of mind, is fighting the Taliban? Nationwide, it is almost exclusively the United States (89%) that is seen as playing this role. Few mention any other country, including Germany (4%) and, the U.K. (3%), with virtually no mention of Canada. Even in Kandahar (where our forces have lost 71 soldiers and counting), it is the U.S. who is seen as the military presence (90%), with only two percent naming Canada. This result is in sharp contrast to the perspective within Canada, where the public is painfully aware of our troop casualties, the highest proportion of any foreign country".

And the Taliban?

When asked, almost three quarters of Afghans nationwide have a very negative (53%) or somewhat negative (20%) opinion of the Taliban, compared with only 14 percent who hold a positive view.

And the more run of the mill questions?:

"A majority (51%) say their country is going in the right direction compared with 28 percent who say it is heading in the wrong direction...six in ten (60%) Afghans say they are personally better off today than they were in 2002...Seven in ten (71%) are very or somewhat positive in their general opinion of the Karzi government (versus 20% who are negative), and six in ten (59%) believe the Karzi government represents their interests as an Afghan".

So, it looks as though the work of NATO is appreciated, and the men on the ground are making a difference. What chance this poll being picked up by the UK media, I wonder?

Labels: ,

Just what has the Foreign Office been telling Pakistan?

Thursday, July 26, 2007
Miliband Major is in Pakistan at the moment, and an anxious nation holds its breath, awaiting his return. So far, so very dull indeed. However, a report on this momentous event in Pakistani newspaper Dawn is remarkably telling:

"Foreign Secretary David Miliband at 41 is the youngest to hold the office in Britain in 30 years. A graduate of Oxford, he is said to be ‘a rising Labour star’ and is seen as a possible future Labour Party leader. His appointment as foreign secretary is perceived in some quarters as a likely shift in British foreign policy to one in which criticism of the US and Israel is not off limits.

Mr Miliband, who earlier served as the Environment secretary in Blair’s final Cabinet, was opposed to the Iraq war and within the Cabinet also criticized the Israeli attack on Hezbollah last year".

Opposed to the Iraq war? Really? Theyworkforyou.com has his voting record, and rates him as having 'voted very strongly for the Iraq war'. I can find no trace of any speeches in the Commons either for, against or firmly on the fence .

Maybe young David only informed other Milibands of his opposition, or maybe the Foreign Office has been feeding a line to a lazy hack who cannot be bothered to check his facts....


I'm off to Doughty St shortly for a bit of political chat, I'm in the 10-11 slot.

Labels: ,

Pakistan's big idea for keeping the Taliban out - a fence

Friday, February 09, 2007
Yes, really. A fence.

"Pakistan's foreign minister has said he seeks European support for his country's plan to fence part of its border with Afghanistan to prevent Taliban fighters from crossing....Musharraf said Pakistan had begun preparations to fence seven or eight locations along its northwest border, stretching 35km. Kasuri said plans to mine the border as well as fence it were abandoned by the government "as a mark of respect to the sensitivity of our European colleagues". Source.

If memory serves, the history of rather more imposing barriers (Maginot Line, anyone?) in keeping out the bad guys has not been good, so this sounds like a waste of good timber and barbed wire.

Labels: ,

Big trouble for Pakistan?

Thursday, January 25, 2007

In what seems like a classic nose / face set-up, the Americans are not from legislating to cut off the tap of military aid to Pakistan: "..new US legislation, already endorsed by the House of Representatives, calls for stopping military assistance to Pakistan if Islamabad fails to halt the resurgence of Taliban inside its territory... It asks that for fiscal years 2008 and 2009, US military assistance to Pakistan “may not be provided” unless the president “determines and certifies” that the Pakistan government is taking all actions against Taliban". (Source)


And there's more, including a long overdue pulling out of the rug from underneath 'our friends the Saudis': "The new provisions form part of the Implementation of 9/11 Commission Recommendations Act, 2007, aimed at revamping the US national security and foreign policy apparatus to address challenges post 9/11. Three countries have been singled out in the proposed legislation: Pakistan, Afghanistan and Saudi Arabia. A congressional aide, who did not want to be identified, told Dawn newspaper that the legislation “shows the general mood in both the chambers, which is not very favourable to Pakistan.”


Labels: ,

Opinion poll corner – India

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

Back to another of my favourite places. Polling by the Hindustan Times makes for happy reading for the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance, in that if elections had been held in January the UPA would have won an outright majority, gaining seats at the expense of the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance.

Both the BJP and Congress are clearly wed to sane economics, and although there are various breeds of Lefties floating around at least one of the Indian parties with a far left identifying name has been keen on privatisation. Not, however, the Communist Party of India (Marxist) , judging from its equivalent of The Worker, which reports on CPI(M)’s affiliated trade union congress: "With a call ‘Forward To Bigger Class Battles’ Pandhe ended his speech saying, ‘We shall overcome one day!’ "

This rabble, plus sundry others form a third group, the Left Front, which with 59 seats holds the balance of power. They are currently supporting the UPA.

A bit more rooting around shows that coalition building in India must be a rather complex process – 39 parties are represented in the Lok Sabha, plus five independents. Congress and the BJP secured less than half of the total vote in 2003, although they are clearly the Big Beasts – the next biggest party, our chums at the CPI(M) took 5.7% of the vote, and the Bahujan Samaj Party, that of the Dalits (or ‘untouchables’) 5.3%.

Just for a point of comparison, there are ten parties plus two independents in Westminster, 10 parties in Moscow, 11 in Paris and six in Berlin.

As a footnote, Sir William Wedderburn, 4th Baronet, was one of the founders of the Indian National Congress.

Labels: ,

More good news from India

Sunday, January 14, 2007
Apparently the Indian retail sector is on the verge of opening up to foreign direct investment, with Tesco, Argos, Dixons etc plus Marks & Spencer (described as 'needing no introduction', which is nice) piling in: "At present, foreign retail investment is restricted by regulation to single-brand retailers. Even then such companies are allowed to own only up to 51 per cent". However, there are hopes that 100% ownership will be possible, and here comes a double take statement: "It will generate over 25 million jobs directly and another 10 million in support in the next five years".

Property next, please.

Labels: ,

It is commonly observed, that when two Indians meet, their first talk is of the weather.

Saturday, January 13, 2007

Apparently it is unseasonally cold in New Delhi at the moment and a hack at the Times of India has been reaching for somewhat excessive meteorological terminology: "Intense cold conditions", "icy northerly winds" and "minimum temperature plummeting".


Erm, it was 4 degrees centigrade last night....

Labels:

Gavels at dawn

Thursday, January 11, 2007
Knowing how much the tale of the battling Greek monks was relished, I now bring you Indian judges going mano a mano:

"A senior judge of the Gujarat High Court allegedly roughed up his colleague when the two were together after their customary morning walk in the Judge's Bungalow area of [Ahmedabad] on Thursday. The incident involved Justices B J Shethna and P B Majmudar...something went wrong and Justice Shethna allegedly started hurling abuses and raining fist-blows on Justice Majmudar".

Maybe Justice Shethna had just had enough of Justice Majmudar's incessant misquoting of Sir Edward Coke, maybe it was a struggle over who got to wear the Black Cap that day, or perhaps it was the wheeling out of 'Judge not that ye be not judged' that pushed Shethna over the edge.

Labels:

Afghan cultural sensitivities..

Wednesday, January 10, 2007
I cannot say that I follow the Indian film industry closely, but I believe it has sparked its first diplomatic row since the 'Rushdie' film, this time with 'Kabul Express', set in Afghanistan at the time of the fall of the Taliban. It is the dialogue that does it, apparently, with the Hazara people described as the '"most dangerous tribe of Afghanistan" for whom "looting is their business."' One of the characters runs through the horrors one might suffer at the hands of the Hazaras, with this deathless pay off: "Then they would have sold your car in Pakistan".

Given that the film has not been in released in Kabul, Kandahar, or come to that the Tora Bora Ritzy, the Afghan government would appear to either have had a Tessa Jowell 'Brass Eye' fit, or else the powers that be have been watching a pirated video tape. Meanwhile, "Afghanistan's Outlook newspaper reported on Saturday that the independent Afghan TV had announced a 72-hour ban on Indian songs or films, a mainstay of Afghan entertainment, in protest" and rather more ominously, the head of the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission thinks "the perpetrators should be brought to justice". Gulp.

Meanwhile, I've had reports of troubles posting since yesterday's blogger maintenance and seen a few multiple postings of comments. Please e-mail me if having problems posting.

Labels: ,

A novel idea from India

Saturday, January 06, 2007

The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, a Hindu nationalist group is just a bit underimpressed with Indian politicians: "The corrupt politician who would not be noticed even by a crow, demands and gets a huge security cover and drives the busy city roads with sirens and gun-toting black cats." I believe the cats in question are miltary types rather than especially talented felines.

Its suggested approach is that "all the security provided to politicians should be withdrawn. Let the political parties spend on private security arrangements or deposit the money spent on security in the government account". That does seem a little drastic, but I do wonder quite how many senior British politicians would be prepared to go out and about without a plethora of security goons trailing them.

Labels:

More on Balochistan

Friday, January 05, 2007
I wrote about this a while back, and have just seen an interesting piece in one of the Indian newspapers.

In essence, Balochistan is very much in play, and the attitude of the US to the independence movemnent would seem to be the core issue, with this less than clear at the moment. Musharaff would be welladvised to stay on the right side of his Uncle Sam, that's for sure.

Labels:

Scope for the Speaker to stick his nose into new places?

There is a mini-scandal afoot in India, with the wife of an MP claiming that he has been having an affair, and she has asked the speaker of the Lok Sabha to investigate. The MP denies it, naturally, but meanwhile she has also contacted both National Human Rights Commission and National Women's Commission.

Admittedly there is the additional element of MP Rajesh Manjhi apparently not paying maintenance, but it would appear that we will not be seeing the pair of them touring the chat show circuit Mark & Belinda Oaten style or posing for cheesy photographs leaning on the garden gate.

I hate to think what the Worst Speaker in Living Memory would do with Red and Blue sex scandals respectively.

Labels:

Squaddies with beards....

Monday, July 17, 2006
There's a rather amusing, if informative tale on the Sky website about Her Majesty's Finest in Afghanistan sporting full sets. This is contrary to usual Army regulations on face fuzz, but some sage has recognised that the culture of Afghanistan requires men to have beards if they want to be regarded as having authority and masculinity. Good for the powers that be showing some fine practical thinking on the matter and I trust it will help in winning hearts and minds.

Here's the tailpiece:

"Lieutenant Rob Phillips leads a twelve-strong patrol from Two-One Air Assault Battery through the town. A luxuriant red beard is revealed when he unstraps his hard hat, before chatting to locals. "To them, it signals I am the commander. They've associated it with authority through all of their culture."



As a footnote, I cultivate a beard every once in a while (varying from a a goatee to a Solzhenitsyn special)and when bearded I do find the world looks quite different, so I can understand the position of the Pashtuns.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, July 04, 2006
British Deaths in Afghanistan

The death of Lance Corporal Hashmi is sad, and certainly newsworthy, but Lord Ahmed of Rotherham goes rather further on the BBC site:


"We should be sympathising with the family of both of the soldiers, particularly the Muslim family because this actually proves the fact that Muslims also give their life for Britain."


What an utterly contemptible comment to make. A little digging suggests that His Lordship keeps some rather questionable company.

And his voting record is worthy of note too.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, June 28, 2006
French special forces in Afghanistan

Trawling through the French papers on line, I've discovered that our friends on the other side of the channel are involved in the military action in Afghanistan. That they decided to sit out Gulf War II is quite well known, but I had assumed they were sitting out this one too.

Anyway, an extract from Le Figaro, which is quite evocative:

Behind a baffle of earth works and the barbed wire perimeter of , you can see flags fluttering in the dust storms. Next to the Afghan and American flags a French flag waves. A little further back there is the Breton Gwenn-ha-Du (means black & white - C ) , doubtless hoisted by homesick marines from Lorient. This old Afghan army barracks, complete with the shell of a 1917 Renault tank..has since summer 2003 been the base for French special Forces in Afghanistan .

Labels: , ,

Sunday, June 25, 2006
An interesting piece in Libération on Christians in Pakistan

Following Iain Dale's comment a few days back about how disappointing he finds international news coverage in the UK press, and a comment maker noting that we tend to blog about whatever is in the UK MSM, I'm trying to cast my net a bit wider and look at news websites from further afield. Anyway, a mooch around Libération (the French equivalent of the Guardian) turned up an item on the lamentable status of Christians in Pakistan.

Here are some extracts, roughly translated:

"A few years ago, a Muslim girl fell in love with one of the pastor’s brothers. "My brother had the whole neighbourhood on his back, people said: "If you marry a Muslim woman we will have you hide", remembers Imran. Here, one does not mix, and my brother did not want to convert. Finally, the girl threw herself under a train."

"...the 1956 Constitution made Pakistan an Islamic Republic. While religious freedom is supposed to be guaranteed, Islam is at the base of the legislation, and all citizens are supposed to live according to its rules. At the end of the Seventies, the county fell under the sway of a radical Islam imposed by dictator Zia ul-Haq, and the minorities, whose members are regarded as second-class citizens, suffered. The law on blasphemy criminalises "those who, by word or writing, gestures or representations, with direct or indirect insinuations, insult the blessed name of the Prophet". Those accused risk life in prison, even hanging. Nearly 700 people,­ of which 10 % were Christians have been imprisoned under this law since 1988”.



It is perhaps worth noting that the white in the Pakistan flag is supposed to represent the country's religious minorities, and it is rather sad that the Churches elsewhere are happy to engage in so much navel gazing rather than concerning themselves a little more with the persecution of Christians in parts of the world where they are a minority.

Labels: